Renault 5 vs Alpine A290: Which One is For You?
We have looked at both the Renault 5 and the Alpine A290 before separately, now we will be directly comparing both of them to find out… which is the choice for you?
Both these cars share the same platform, but these siblings are engineered for vastly different drivers. Let’s dive into what sets these two hatchbacks apart.
Design
Both cars proudly embrace their heritage, but their visual interpretations couldn’t be more distinct.
The Renault 5 E-Tech embraces a delightful modern-retro aesthetic. It contains features that are loving nods to the iconic original from the 1970s. With signature square headlights, and a vibrant palette of colours including Pop Yellow and Pop Green making it sure to stand out!
Conversely, the Alpine A290 is a pure adrenaline rush on wheels. It takes the Renault 5 platform and transforms it into something far more aggressive. Noticeably, lower and wider it’s completely redesigned but still the same? It features unique X-shaped headlights, inspired by classic rally cars, and striking 19 inch “snowflake” alloy wheels (a tribute to Alpine’s mountainous origins). It looks much sportier and oriented towards performance.
Interior
Taking a look inside, and the shared platform is evident but the ambience is totally different…
The Renault 5 offers a clean and user-friendly cabin. With a large central touchscreen, intuitive physical controls, and great handy features like wireless phone charging, Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, and an incredible 48 ambient lighting options. A great bit about the interior of the Renault 5, the seats are crafted from recyclable denim, and they are super comfy and feel premium!
In the Alpine A290, the focus sharpens on the driver. Sportier seats, darker materials, and a slightly lower driving position creates an immersive cockpit feel. The F1-inspired steering wheel is more sculpted, and features a thrilling “OV” (Overtake) button for an instant power surge. It also has a 10.1” infotainment system which isn’t just for navigation, it provides live performance data, voice assistance and real time traffic updates.
Performance
This is where these two cars truly start to differ…
The Renault 5 E-Tech is built for the everyday. It’s light, responsive, and smooth, making it a joy to navigate city streets and handle varied road conditions . The top-spec model delivers a respectable 150 bhp, accelerating from 0-62 mph in around 8 seconds. Its light steering and comfortable suspension prioritize ease of driving and urban agility. It is designed to be the perfect city car, and it’s a fine drive!
The Alpine A290 is a different breed entirely—a dedicated performance machine. Boasting up to 220 bhp and a blistering 0-62 mph time of just 6.4 seconds, it offers a significantly more potent and engaging drive. Its unique front subframe, 60mm wider axles, and advanced suspension geometry, including hydraulic bump stops (a nod to the Renault Sport Megane), ensure exceptional handling. The steering is faster, more precise, and offers greater resistance, delivering a truly connected feel. While firmer, the ride remains composed and well-damped, even on challenging roads. The A290 also features customisable regenerative braking with four settings, allowing for near one-pedal driving, and that exhilarating “OV” button for a temporary burst of power.
Practicality
Despite their performance disparities, both vehicles are remarkably similar in their practical offerings.
Both the Renault 5 E-Tech and the Alpine A290 are compact five-door hatchbacks with identical boot capacities. They provide 326 liters of boot space, expanding to over 1,100 liters with the rear seats folded. Rear passenger space is comparable, suitable for shorter trips but potentially snug for taller occupants on longer journeys.
When it comes to electric range, both vehicles offer competitive figures for their class, though with slight variations reflecting their different performance priorities. The Renault 5 E-Tech, designed with everyday usability in mind, boasts an impressive electric range of up to 252 miles (WLTP). This makes it a highly practical choice for daily commutes and longer journeys alike.
The Alpine A290, while sharing the same 52kWh battery as its sibling, sees a slight reduction in range due to its performance-oriented tuning and wider stance. It offers an electric range of up to 236 miles (WLTP). While marginally less than the Renault 5, this still provides ample range for spirited driving and everyday use, without significant range anxiety for most drivers.
Conclusion
Your Drive, Your Choice
The Alpine A290 and the Renault 5 are suited for different types of drivers. The Renault 5 is there as an ideal companion for those who seek a stylish, practical and accessible electric vehicle for daily life, blending iconic design with modern efficiency. It’s a car that brings joy to every journey.
Whereas, for the driving enthusiast, the Alpine A290 is the clear winner. It’s a finely tuned performance machine, delivering exhilarating power, razor-sharp handling and a brilliant design. This one is for the thrill seekers!
Ultimately, the choice between these two compelling options is up to you and your personal preference. Do you desire everyday usability and something catered for a city drive? Or do you crave something more performance-driven and filled with excitement? Both are great choices at the end of the day.
« « Volkswagen’s new ID.Polo: Say hello to the new compact EV | The Maxus T60 MAX – a pick-up that is ready for adventure » »
